always revising

I don't know how they do it, those professional recipe writers. How does one decide a recipe is finally done, and ready to find its place in a cookbook? How can you ever be sure you've hit on the best version? Me, I'm always playing with my recipes, switching up the flours, sweeteners, flavors. For this site, I make sure the recipes I post are versions that (at that moment, at least) I truly love. But I'd rarely say they're done.

Case in point: early in the life of this blog, I wrote a post about biscuits. I wrote about how part of my love for them was the way they connected me to my husband's side of the family, and through them the rich history of Southern cooking I'm able to tap into. I'm not taking any of that back.

But the recipe? Yes, I'm replacing it. Now, don't get me wrong, it's still a good recipe, and because of all the generational ties it creates, I'm keeping it in our family stash. But I have to admit I've found a new favorite. And the thing I find really funny? The recipe isn't that much different! It's less sweet (no sugar or coconut flour) and has less butter in it, so it's healthier for you. And I've mixed up the flours a bit, resulting in a biscuit that I'd swear has a bit of wheat in it (thanks to the teff). But really, it's still a pretty typical Southern buttermilk biscuit recipe. It's so interesting to me, to realize what a big difference minimal changes to a recipe can make!

Well, truthfully? While I'm extremely pleased, I'm not actually that surprised by the changes in flavor - lots of past experimentation means I'm well-versed in the ways gentle tweaks of the gluten-free flours used can result in significant alterations to the flavor profile. I guess what really shocked me was noting that I'd used less butter this time around, yet the biscuits lost none of the tenderness or richness of their predecessors! I don't have the two versions side-by-side to compare, but I'm willing to go out on a limb and say that these new ones might actually be more tender and satisfying than the old ones.

I attribute this largely to the teff. Or, more accurately, to replacing the coconut flour with teff. Coconut flour is lovely to bake with, and I really appreciate the flavor it adds. But it's texture is definitely on the grittier end of the gluten-free flours scale. And teff? Well, it's one of the finest grains you can get (by which I mean it's small, although it's a pretty darn good grain, as well), and it's great in gluten-free baked goods, where so often we're trying to replicate the soft, finely-milled texture of wheat flour.

Also, the method is, um . . . updated, shall we say? I don't think it's very traditional to use the food processor for biscuits (I absolutely can not imagine Josh's grandmother doing it this way!), but, like with pastry dough, it really benefits the end product. In addition to making for a quick and easy method, it aerates the flours, which is always good. It also keeps the butter as cold as possible, meaning that you'll maximize the steam created as the butter melts during baking.

So, softer flour, colder (albeit less) butter, and no sugar. Writing it out like that makes these biscuits sound pretty unremarkable, when in fact they are quite remarkable! They have the best scent, for one thing. Yes, during baking, but also afterwards, when they've been sitting out on the cooling rack for an hour, and you're about to wrap up the leftovers. That scent, that lingering, rich, nutty, wheaty scent, makes you decide that maybe you need just one more before you're done for the day. Honestly, as much as I love bread products, it's usually the sweet, not savory, baked goods that make me unable to resist yet another bite. These biscuits could be a turning point for me.

And the flavor is just as good as the scent promises. I really don't know what to say about it. I mean, on the one hand, they're just biscuits; do they really deserve any more gushing and fawning over than I've already afforded them? But on the other hand, gluten-free biscuits that are a breeze to make and taste like some of the best gluten-full biscuits you've ever had? That is reason to celebrate! So I'll just tell you this: I made a batch and brought them to our family's 4th of July picnic, to use for strawberry shortcakes. As I was eating my shortcake, I kept scraping aside the strawberries and whipped cream, because I just wanted bites of plain biscuit. And after everyone had their fill of shortcake? At least two (non-gluten-free eaters!) went back for seconds, of only the biscuit, because it was so good. If that's not enough to convince you to make these biscuits, I don't know what would.

You know, I think I may just be ready to call this recipe done. For at least the next six months.

Buttermilk Biscuits, v2.0
yields about 8 biscuits

1 cup minus 1 Tbsp Tara's all-purpose gluten-free flour mix
1 cup minus 1 Tbsp Tara's gluten-free pastry flour mix
2 Tbsp teff flour
1 tsp xanthan gum
1/4 tsp baking soda
1 Tbsp baking powder
1 tsp kosher salt
6 Tbsp butter, cold, cubed
3/4 cup buttermilk (approximate)

Preheat oven to 450ยบ. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a silicone baking sheet.

Combine the flours, xanthan gum, baking soda, baking powder, and salt in the bowl of a food processor, and pulse to thoroughly combine.

Add the cold butter pieces, and pulse just until most pieces are pea-sized. Pour in the buttermilk, pulsing just until the dough comes together. (Keep an eye on the dough as you do this - depending on your flours and buttermilk, you may need slightly less than 3/4 cup buttermilk for it to form a cohesive dough. You want to stop adding liquid before it turns wet and sticky.)

Turn the dough out onto a gf-floured board, and gently pat (don't roll!) in into a 1-inch thick round. Cut with a biscuit cutter, round cookie cutter, even a glass will work. You can pat the scraps back into a round and cut them also, but they won't be quite as fluffy and tender. Place the biscuits on the prepared baking sheet.

Bake for 10-15 minutes, or until golden brown. Cool on a rack, for as long as you can stand the wait. Serve warm, with good butter and honey, or fruit preserves, or eggs and bacon, or sausage gravy (goodness, I'm getting hungry just typing this!), or let them fully cool and make your favorite shortcakes. They are also phenomenal completely unadorned.


  1. Hello,
    I just found your blog tonight - and your food photos are making me really hungry. Especially that Chocolate Orange Cake.

  2. Elizabeth - I tend to read food blogs at night, and always end up hungry right before bed! But at least I'm assured of some good inspiration for the next day. Thanks for stopping by, and welcome!

  3. Tara,
    I was just introduced to your blog today and love it. It's so beautifully done with loving care. The photos, writing, layout and best of all yummy recipes make it a keeper.

    I have one question about this biscuit recipe. Did you intend to repeat the first ingredient - 1 cup minus 1 Tbsp Tara's gluten-free pastry flour mix? Just want to be sure that it uses almost 2 cups of flour and not 1.

    Btw, we made a shortbread recipe yesterday that looked a lot like your photo, albeit flatter.

    Thanks - Judy

  4. Judy - yes, it is two cups total flour. 1 cup minus 1 Tbsp each my all-purpose mix and pastry mix, plus 2 Tbsp teff to make up the difference. Thank you for asking.

    And thank you so much for visiting - I'm so pleased you enjoy my blog. I'll bet your shortbread were delicious!

  5. Thank you so much for this recipe. It was delicious.
    I make a modified Peter Reinhart biscuit for the non GFers in the family and I've been missing my biscuits. I've tried so many GF biscuit recipes and they were terrible ,the dogs wouldn't even eat them!
    I subbed millet for the sorghum in the AP flour mix and 1/3 C each of arrowroot starch and cornstarch for the potato starch in the pastry flour mix. The recipe worked fine.
    Thank you for giving this southerner back her biscuits.

    1. Oh Kari, I'm so glad to hear that! I'm especially glad to hear the recipe worked with your substitutions. I think the best recipes are ones that can be adapted to individual needs and preferences, and still come out great. I'm happy to hear this biscuit recipe falls in that category!

  6. These look amazing! Looking at that shot of butter melting over halved biscuit, I can practically smell the warm, buttery tang. Can't wait to give these a try! Gorgeous photos. Looking forward to perusing your beautiful blog some more. : ) Love NoshOn.It!

  7. This is a terrific biscuit and very adaptable - thank you! I found them wonderful fresh and even after a week in the fridge, toasted up stupendously.

  8. don't have access to teff. any suggestions? thanks:)

    1. The teff is mostly for the flavor it lends, so any gf flour that you like will work here. Do you have access to gf oat flour? That would be nice here. Or millet, quinoa, buckwheat and amaranth would all be fun to play with!

  9. Replies
    1. My local grocery store stocks xanthan gum in the gluten-free section, and most natural foods stores carry it as well (sometimes in the bulk section, sometimes in retail packaging with the other gluten-free goods). Good luck!

  10. Hi, just found your blog. These biscuits are to die for! Thank you. Just made them and puff they're gone. I live in Denmark and can't get xanthan gum so I used psyllium Husk 1:1 instead and it worked perfectly.
    Pia from Denmark


Creative Commons License